1. Enemies of the State
2. Enemies of a U.S. Ally, Israel
3. Hatemongers and Anti Semites
Before our two representatives begin proposing solutions for the Palestinian people’s problems, I think that may want to do a little homework in the form of a historical analysis to discover how the “problems” got to where they are today.
A clear-eyed analysis should suggest to these Reps that Israel is not the Palestinians’ main problem and that BDS is not the solution. These smart Congresswomen may want to become better informed so as to avoid any future type of exploitation that can be visited upon those who ignore the ancient Maxim, “It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak up and remove all doubt.”
With a little appreciation and respect for history and the significance of historical facts…you don’t need to look much before 1948, when Israel declared its independence…and when the surrounding Arab world began preparing for the slaughter. It is fair to say that those Arabs who were living within the borders of the newly formed state of Israel at the time, sized up their prospects for survival and not( necessarily) unwisely, decided that they wanted to be on the winning side.
It is important to note that notwithstanding all of the legalistic arguments and all the political machinations whirling about the League of Nations and the U N. during this period prior to 1948, Jewish people, in fact, had lived in what is now the Arab world for over 2,600 years, a 1,000 years before Islam was founded, and centuries before the Arab conquest of many of those territories. The term Jewish people refers to a group of people whose common religion, customs, laws, and culture existed…even long before 2600 years ago AND long before the word “Palestine” even existed in anybody’s language. The other indigenous people in the region were comprised of various Bedouin tribes, whose cultures were most notably marked by their nomadic nature, whereas the contemporaneous Jewish communities existed throughout the region, sometimes as Jewish kingdoms and Governments.
So, let’s just note for the record that prior to the late 19th century, when the region began to evolve into a little more than the sand, sagebrush and some newly established railroad tracks, the legal claims on the land were “up for grabs”.
When 1948 came along and Israel’s independence happened, the Arab world’s emotional reaction ranged between “somewhat upset”…and “stark raving mad”… the latter description garnering most of the votes. The Arab world simply could not abide the UN’s decision to recognize tiny Israel, which not incidentally, represented less than 1% of all of the land controlled by surrounding Arab countries. And then the drumbeat began…and it has not missed a beat for the last 71 years: “Death to the Jews” and “Push Them Into the Sea”. These catchy chants actually evolved later into a rock-solid negotiating position by the representatives of those 1948 runaways, who many years later in a very “Johnny come lately” manner surveyed with greed and envy the now blooming land that was looking so much more attractive. So many demands…so many chants.
Funny thing about chants. They are not very instructive. And if they are not work-related (“Whistle while you work”), they are also counterproductive. I can’t seem to remember any such chants coming from the people on the Israeli side of the fence, including those Arab folks who chose to remain (or take the opportunity to return immediately) for the hard work. They also were too busy making the land bloom to be wasting time conjuring up hate chants.
The Palestinian leadership has fanned the flames of bitterness, grievance, and victimhood for the last 71 years. It has not been productive. Staking out a non-negotiable position of “Death to the Jews” and “Push Them Into the Sea” is also a road to the nowhere condition that now exists for most Palestinians.
Perhaps trying to work together with the Israelis, who seem to have done a pretty good job with the sliver of land they have been able to control, might be a good idea. Why not advocate for that idea, instead of sticking to the exploitative ideas of the PLO and its progeny. Instead of singing lead sopranos in the “Death to the Jews Choir”, you may also want to use your influence to explain to Saudi Arabia that the billions of dollars that they have spent on Gaza for the last 20 years could be better spent. Rather than wasting money on secret tunnels to smuggle in weapons of mass destruction; rather than buying favor with luxury condos for the corrupt PA exploiters of the Palestinian people…try actually improving their lives…unless you are afraid of an informed, free and dignified people living next door.
Ms. Tlaib Rashida would like you to believe that she, as a Palestinian native, who has personally suffered the oppressive whip of Israeli brutality, is some sort expert. She was born and raised in Detroit. Her Grandmother, however, is a resident of the Palestinian Arab village of Beit Ur al-Fauqa, a village that has been governed by the Palestinian Authority since 1995… when the Israeli occupation of that village ended. It is just a tad disingenuous for the congresswoman to claim that her grandmother is “occupied” by the Israelis — and therefore she and Grandma are victims of persecution, and they are “expert” eyewitnesses to Israeli “human rights violations”.
The United States elections of 2020 hopefully will soon be upon us. Let’s hope that the results will usher in a farewell to wretched, hateful, misinformed politics for a long time.
so how does your title have anything to do with your thesis?
If you want Palestinians to start co-operating with Israel, it might help for Israeli soldiers to stop shooting Palestinian schoolchildren.
And using snipers to do so.
If the people in the USA ever see how the Israelis treat the Palestinians, Israel’s credibility is gone.
Short-sighted and inaccurate thesis
Allow me to be a little less short-sighted and a little more accurate for future reference.
Congresswomen Rashida Tlaib of Michigan and Ilhan Omar of Minnesota are official elected Representatives to the highest legislative body in the United States, and they and our country (who they represent) have been egregiously disrespected by two ancient political heretics, the current POTUS, Donald Trump and the leader of our ally, Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu. Their time in office and their ability to influence events will soon be over. The good news is that our new Congresswomen could and should convert this negative behavior into a positive result.
These women are smart, compassionate and sincere, and they are in a position to begin to create a platform for an informed and just settlement of the Israeli Palestinian conflict in a way that has never before been attempted.
Their reputations for fairness and compassion will provide them with an unprecedented opportunity to advance understanding and justice…and to create a framework for real, comprehensive, well informed, fair peace talks.
First, in their official capacities, they should both demand to schedule a fact-finding visit to Israel, the mission of which is investigate how well they may be able to “kickstart” meaningful peace talks, including participation by local troublemaking nations and other non-nation entities, whose interests may be inconsistent with their ideas of peace.
This will not be easy. It will require hard work and the courage to require a public endorsement and an acknowledgment by all parties of Israel’s right to exist within defensible borders.
Without such a public acceptance (of Israel’s right to exists), no real discussions can happen. This is the challenge that can create a realistic framework, which may one day accomplish more for the Palestinians, the Israelis…and the World… than anyone has ever achieved before.
Jewish and Arab culture once led the world in enlightenment by teaching ancient and wise principles.
Now that Western Civilization has demonstrated that in their “omniscience” they may have overlooked a few basic survival precepts, it may be time to look elsewhere for some solutions, such as:
1. How do we learn to control ourselves individually and as societies so that we can live in harmony with nature in a way that we do not choke ourselves to death in our own homes?
2. How do we develop living environments that eliminate the conditions that make possible mass murder?
3. How do we learn from our mistakes?
4. How often will we need to apply #3 to #s 1 and #2?
These women may very well usher in an age of bridges versus obstacles; of unity over divisiveness; of success over conflict.
Storm clouds may soon pass, and the sun may soon shine again.
That is my long-term forecast.