For those of you who may be wondering, GOP Vice Presidential candidate JD Vance’s given birth name is James Donald Bowman. He was adopted. When his mother erased the name of his father, Donald Bowman from the files, the adoption process erased his name from the files. The only official name on file is James Donald Hamel, presumably his adopted name. In April of 2013 the young man legally changed his last name from Hamel to Vance, supposedly in honor of his grandmother. This information comes courtesy of an AP report available on Google.
Dear God, what a lineal history. I’m not here to ridicule, nor to be sarcastic. Most people never change their names. In fact, I’m heartbroken for the boy. Most people never change their names. But from what I understand, if a mother chooses to erase the father’s name from the birth record, it is not unusual fror the adoption process to substitute the name of the adoptive family to spare the child from discovering the painful history of their early past.
But it makes Vance emotionally a witches brew of contradictions. For instance, I noticed that Vance didn’t legally change his name until 2013, when he was a senior at Yale. Oddly enough this was about the same time that his autobiographical book Hillbilly Elegy came out. Since the name of the author on the book is JD Vance, I can only assume that he changed his name legally before publication.
But this raises a simple question about Hillbilly Elegy. *Full Disclosure* I have not personally read Hillbilly Elegy. But from what I understand, it is a heart wrenching tale of poverty, abuse and deprivation. But given Vance’s available lineage, how much of his tale took place as a Bowman, and how much, if any as a Hamel?
Whatever the combination, if any, one thing we have empirical data on. The mental and emotional characteristics of a child are predominately formed in the first 16 years of life. And we also know that historically, in poor white, rural environments, the male opinion of women hasn’t changed since King Arthur ruled the Round Table. Women are chattel property. They’re there to bear children, keep the house clean, and put dinner on the table. And the penalty for non compliance can be severe. And nobody else will care.
Which, when you think about it, goes a long way towards explaining Vance’s rather extreme right wing political views regarding women and children. Look, from where I’m sitting, JD Vance pulled himself up by the bootstraps when he didn’t even have a goddamned pair of boots, and he deserves all the credit in the world. But to paraphrase an old saying, You can take the boy out of the hillbilly, but you can’t take the hillbilly out of the boy. And Vance was, is, and always will be that hillbilly.
Which explains his absurd and Neanderthal positions on women, children, and reproductive rights. Vance grew up in that atmosphere, it is ingrained, and nothing that has happened to him in his life since he improved himself has given him any reason to change his mind. And while he has moderated his public utterances to be more genteel, his opinions are what they are.
Which is fane and dindy fine and dandy if you’re a soulless venture capitalist robber baron, it’s a definite shortcoming when you’re running for political office, especially on a nationwide ticket.
The first thing a politician learns is how to take personal feelings and opinions that may be unpalatable for the general population, and lock those away in the closet and instead bring out socially and acceptable opinions and bromides. Vance has never had to do that. In what public speaking he has experience in, it’s likely in situations with other venture capitalist robber barons who likely secretly share his views.
When you see JD Vance on the campaign trail, what you see Vance unfiltered. Because that’s all that JD Vance knows how to be. And being as egotistical as Traitor Tot, Vance’s automatic response to critics of his Piltdown Man views of women and families is that they can go and f*ck themselves. Because Vance is not a political creature, he never learned how to walk back a f*ck up in a follow up interview. See Vance’s incomprehensible word salad when asked to walk back his comment about cat ladies.
This is what happens when imbeciles like Traitor Tot don’t bother to properly vet Vice Presidential candidates. While nothing in Vance’s childhood history may not have raised any red flags, might in fact have been inspirational, any serious in person vetting of Vance, including probing him on his personal opinions of sensitive topics, would have proven in five minutes that Vance is an old school redneck hillbilly, and completely incapable of moderating his views and opinions to meet the political climate. But El Pendejo ex President was dead sure he had a lock on the election, and wanted Vance around to run up the low class rural vote to make it a blowout. Marry in haste, and repent at leisure.Â
I thank you for the privilege of your time.






















there was vetting, they were just looking at non-standard characteristics like obsequiousness and non being significantly more intelligent than Trump (that must have been a tough one). when it’s over, they will not view that as an error.
And to add on: they never in a million years expected Joe to step down. Hence Vance is younger–for any voters who may have figured out that Trump was only three years younger than Joe, had Peter Thiel in his corner, and to their thinking wouldn’t give Donald one bit of grief or push back to anything no matter how awful he wanted to do.
Talk about turning the tables in one afternoon. And now the enthusiasm, money and voters are headed our way at long last. We do have to be on alert—as James Carville says, “the cuts are coming.” But Kamala knows how to handle this crap and Trump is a mess, plus saddled with a very unpopular VP candidate who won’t be able to do one thing to bail him out.
Payback is hell.
According to Andy Beshear, Governor of Kentucky, Vance is full of it. He didn’t grow up in Kentucky in the poverty he describes. He visited his grandparents in Kentucky during the summer and then went back to a fairly well off household. Which basically makes Hillbilly Elegy belong in the fiction section. That’s the part that blows my mind.
He’s not impressing people with this argument that childless people (of either gender) are second class citizens. There are a LOT of reasons people don’t have children and I don’t think that they’re lesser human beings because of it. I should say, “we’re” lesser human beings because of it, because I also am a “childless cat lady” if that’s how this asshole wants to categorize me and make me less than, not as good as. That’s up to him.
I am.a married childless cat lady. My first husband and I couldn’t afford kids: childcare was too expensive and I made twice as much as he did. After being widowed I remarried to a sailor who had a,vas.
The party has until August 7th to replace Shady JD.
DK has an article about John Hamel (hillbilly boy’s real name) written by a Kentuckian who also read the prat’s book–https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2024/7/26/2258316/-Tom-Bowman-is-a-Carpetbagger?pm_campaign=trending&pm_source=sidebar&pm_medium=web
I haven’t read the book and have no desire nor intention to do so but I have lived in the state and I can vouch for a couple of things in KY Hemp Dude’s article: there are no county mayors. In fact, I had never even heard the words County and Mayor, together, as a title for anyone serving in a representational/governmental/etc. position ever. There sure as all get out aren’t any County Mayors in KY. I also took some of my sociology undergraduate courses (required electives) in the UK system one of which was a history course. The professor knew about the term Bloody Breathitt (county) and explained the reference–civil war and NOT WW I. So, right there we have two pieces of bull crap. When a book of “non-fiction” has in a casual reading two lies, I figure the whole thing is full of them so even if I was interested in hillbilly boy’s life, I would have been turned off right from the get-go.
It will be interesting to see what von shitzi’s campaign does with Hamel. I expect he’s on the ticket because he not only gives it a cachet of rural to it (a lie but anyone who will vote for von shitzi will buy it) but he also can speak in complete sentences which will make him seem quite erudite to potential von shitzi voters. It will be interesting to see if they can get him to shut his yap because they sure as shit can’t get von shitzi to do so.
He’s a fraud, therefore he should fit right in with the grifter in chief. I’m a real ‘hillbilly’ from the hills and hollers in NW NC and SW Virginia. There’s nothing about him that’s authentic.
I’m from the suburbs of a small city in Pennsylvania, but many of my cousins have quite rural roots in the southern mid-West and all of them have pulled themselves up by the bootstraps. They’d never recognize what in the heck Vance is peddling about rural life—but then, from all the analyses of his past I’ve read, it’s just shit he made up to sell books and remake himself into a sympathetic character for the type of folks who were already in the process of becoming MAGA followers.
Thank you for clearing up some information for me about “Vance.” I knew about all the name changes but not the legalities of each name change and I’m still quite skeptical about the motives, especially with “Vance” as a pretense to seem closer to actual Appalachian residents who are his relatives. As a good Dem, I will call you by whatever name you want no matter the reason for the change. But, this guy is a standard-bearer for a political party with policies against changing your birth name and continues to taunt trans folk with dead names years after they changed them! So, I will continue to taunt “Vance.” Were I in a position to interview him, I would begin “Sen Vance, if that is your real name…..”
I was adopted. Haven’t ever changed my name. But that doesn’t mean other people can’t do it. Wait!!! Don’t teapublicons always say “My way or the highway.” Does this mean JDV will make me change my name two or three times?
The fact that the book was published as by J.D. Vance” does not necessarily mean that he had legally changed it by then, It could just have been a “nom de plume” that he liked so much he later made it legal. And – apparently – the “J.D.” is the ony part of what he calls himself that’s real. Now that upsets me, because my initials are J and D and there are people who call me by them. But my complaint is miniscule beside that of Joyce Vance (who has published a photo of herself holding an angry-looking Maine Coon as a rejoinder to – um – J.D.
I particularly loved his state!ent that childless people should pay more in taxes, which makes no sense. Childless people actually *save* the country because we use fewer resources. We don’t use funds for educating our kids because,we don’t have any kids in public schools or needing student loans.We don’t lower our income tax by getting childcare benefits nor extra deductions for having reproduced. In fact we are subsiding OPCs ( Other People’s Children).