And, like clockwork, some “progressives” are coming together in an attempt to give control of the US Senate back to the Republicans. Let the backstabbing begin. Again.

Politico reports: “Progressive PAC kick-starts search for challengers to Manchin, Sinema.”

So. Let’s look at some numbers. Right now, the Democrats hold 50 seats in the U.S. Senate. The only reason they have a “majority” is because we have a Democratic president. Vice President Harris can cast a deciding vote in case there isn’t a majority — and she already has.

This is a razor-thin majority by any measure. A single Democrat can pass away, or refuse to vote with the majority, or change parties, or any of a number of things that will stop Democrats from controlling the Senate.

It only takes one to lose the majority.

n 2023, 14 Democrats and 20 Republicans are up for re-election. Most of these seats are going to stay either red or blue, with a few chances to flip seats. It’s way too early to say, but a cautiously optimistic view is to say that the Democrats might be able to extend their majority by a couple of seats.

But, hey, the progressives — at least, the progressives behind this move — have a different idea! Let’s attack two Democratic incumbents and give those seats back to the GOP!

Of course, that isn’t how they frame it. They have two juicy targets in their sights, Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema. And they’re not wrong to point out that they are a) pretty conservative for Democrats and b) vulnerable. I get it. Manchin only votes with the Democrats maybe 75% of the time, and Sinema not much more. Both are opposed to eliminating the Senate filibuster, and both are seen as wobbly on strong climate change legislation.

So. The No Excuses PAC — a combative name, that — founded by Saikat Chakrabarti, Corbin Trent and Zack Exley, say they want to remove Democrats who “stan[d] in the way of ambitious action to end the coronavirus pandemic and revive the economy.”

Both Manchin and Sinema voted to support the $1.9 trillion pandemic response bill. But never mind pesky facts.

Two of the PAC founders, Chakrabarti and Trent, are former staffers for Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. (I have enormous affection and respect for AOC, even though she goes way off the rails sometimes.) They either don’t realize or don’t care that a candidate like her will not win in a lot of areas in the United States. Say, Senate seats in Arizona and West Fucking Freaking Virginia. Politico reports:

In an email to supporters Tuesday, the PAC will say, “Help us find the next AOC to replace Manchin and Sinema.”

Really. They think an Ocasio-Cortez or Nina Turner or Bernie Sanders is going to win in those states. Sorry. They’re wrong.

Let me give a contrast. I live in North Carolina, a classic purple state that is gerrymandered to the hilt. (The electorate is split almost 50-50, but Republicans hold 10 of the 13 US House seats and have an iron grip on the state legislature.) I live in NC-7, which was until recently represented by the redoutable Blue Dog, Mike McIntyre. I detested McIntyre and wanted him gone. Well, I got my wish. In 2014, McIntyre retired, likely because he didn’t think he would win re-election. For six years and counting, we’ve been “represented” by the Tea Party corporatist David Rouzer, who wants to destroy our district’s beaches with unfettered offshore drilling, voted to overturn the 2020 presidential election, and apparently thinks QAnon is a pretty fly bunch of white guys.

I’d take McIntyre back in a heartbeat.

Manchin and Sinema are the equivalents of McIntyre. Arizona is a lot like North Carolina, quite purple and prone to put idiots like Joe Arpaio, Doug Ducey, Paul Gosar, Evan Mechum, Jan Brewer, and Martha McSally into office. The Democrats they vote in tend to be left-leaning centrists like Mark Kelly and his wife Gabrielle Gifford, Janet Napplitano, and the Udall brothers. Arizona voters are not going to vote for a desert version of AOC to represent them in the Senate. Kelly and Sinema won in part because they assured the Arizona voters that they wouldn’t toe the Democratic line in the Senate, and they were respectful and receptive to more conservative views.

As for Manchin, are they serious? This is West Virginia. Have they ever been to that state? State voters sent centrist Democrat Jay Rockefeller to the Senate because, well, he was a Rockefeller and he was relatively conservative on some issues. Same with Manchin. As for the state legislature, the Republicans hold a 74-24 majority in the House and a 20-14 majority in the Senate. Manchin survives in West Virginia the same way McIntyre did in North Carolina, and Kelly and Sinema do in Arizona — by reassuring voters that he was conservative in many ways, and that he would operate independently of the Democratic leadership when needed. (Manchin may retire in 2022, which means that the West Virginia Democrats can either find someone “Manchin-like” to run or try to run someone like Paula Jean Swearingen, who got clobbered by a 43-point margin against Manchin’s Republican colleague Shelly Moore Caputo in the 2020 Senate race. Maybe they can run centrist Earl Ray Tomblin; he’s a few years younger than Manchin. The No Excuses PAC would love him. Not.)

The PAC leaders who want to eject Sinema and Manchin aren’t stupid. They have to understand that their attempt to “find an AOC” to run to replace Sinema and Manchin will almost certainly not work, regardless of how many cheery slogans and references to the Spartans at Thermopylae they may chant. Chakrabarti burbled:

The only real way to pressure any of these folks and hold them accountable to their promises is to threaten their power, and threaten the seat that they hold and threaten their reelection. We sort of have this theory that the voters in Arizona and the voters in West Virginia would care more about action, they care more about jobs and their community and money in their pockets than they do about an arcane Senate rule called the filibuster.

Well, for one, he totally contradicted himself about the filibuster — yo, bro, I thought that’s one of the reasons why you wanted to primary them, because of their resistance to ending the filibuster? — and for two, I guarantee that if he bothered to analyze the Sinema and Manchin campaigns, he would find they centered their campaigns on kitchen-table issues. I doubt either one of them said a word about the filibuster on the campaign trail.

Reporters Laura Barron-Lopez and Holly Otterbein note two things:

This new effort is also likely to frustrate leading Democrats as they attempt to keep the party united while corralling their small majorities in the House and Senate to pass Biden’s agenda.


In taking on Manchin and Sinema, the political action committee will be trying to accomplish something the left has struggled to achieve in recent years: compete in conservative and swing seats. Justice Democrats has so far failed to flip a Republican-held district.

What they could do is try to get more Democrats — even center-left Dems, shudder — into the Arizona and West Virginia legislatures, let them get experience, build their brands, and then run them for office. But no, that’s not the plan. They want to raise gobs of money, smear Manchin and Sinema from the left, and weaken them for the 2022 races.

Upshot: Democrats will have to flip two seats just to keep their razor-thin majority. Or we get to have Mitch McConnell back as Majority Leader, to block everything the House passes and cripple the Biden administration.

Wanna convince me that the “No Excuses” PAC isn’t deliberately doing this? You’re going to have to convince me that they’re either blithering idiots who don’t get the damage they are doing, or they are fanatics who think they actually have a real shot at getting a progressive into either of those seats, despite all evidence to the contrary.

The first is almost certainly not true. Chakrabarti said:

Pressuring them in 2022 when Dems may no longer have a majority won’t do much.

So they do know what they’re doing.

Whether they are fifth columnists trying to give the Senate back to the Republicans or they’re fanatics who are blinded by rhetoric and ideology, McConnell and the GOP send their thanks.

Help keep the site running, consider supporting.


  1. Dems are a true “big tent” party with very diverse views and ideas of how to do things and priorities in very diverse regions of the country unlike Republicans who are told who to vote for and what to think as they nod obediently.

    Ideas and positions that would get you elected in NY-14 wouldn’t get you past the primary in VA-07. The sooner that fact is realized the better.

  2. I lived in WV for over ten and a half years before moving to NC. Also, I grew up in southern Illinois which is remarkably like WV from incredible natural beauty to heartbreaking poverty throughout the region. In both places one of the few bright spots for good paying jobs was coal, and in both places the industry has been dying a long, slow death. Like farming, coal mining is a generational thing in families and even entire small towns and while objectively things like retraining for 21st century jobs (with taxpayer help) is a no-brainer reality on the ground is something very different. In addition, both places have a long history of racism and while poor white people will eagerly seek and accept things like SNAP and other assistance they don’t want “those” people to get them because they are convinced that while they deserve it “those people” don’t. And they will cut off their noses to spite their faces to prove their point. The hypocrisy is lost on them, and to a startling degree so is the ingrained racism. So many will hotly deny being racist because “I have friends that are black. Or from south of the border, etc. There was an expression I heard all the time growing up – “good n-word” and THAT is generationally ingrained to this day.

    I though Manchin was a P.O.S. when I lived in WV and nothing about him since has changed my mind. I wish to hell we could get better than him, but much as I hate to say it we are lucky he’s stuck around. 75% (or even less some years) is a helluva lot better than zero or very close to it which is what we’d have without Manchin. Just take a look at his voting record compared to “moderate” (well, she used to be considered that) GOP Senator Shelley Moore Capito! I remember when she ran for Rockefeller’s seat even though she had a rock solid gig in the House. I even got to meet her opponent and had a nice chat with her and Jay after a campaign event in Martinsburg (WV). I can’t even remember he name now but she seemed a bit more progressive than Rockefeller and had good people skills on the campaign trail. And she got CREAMED by Capito!

    So yes, I’ll say it again that it sucks that Manchin is the best we can hope for out of WV but that’s the way it is and things won’t change anytime soon. Maybe someday, just like happened in Virginia but while Virginia turned blue it’s still LIGHT blue (albeit getting a little deeper blue each cycle) it took something like twenty years to make it happen. Twenty years of putting up with frustrating moderates (I lived in VA for the better part of two decades before WV) and it was only recently that we started picking up sustainable momentum. Could that someday take place in WV? Sure. But now and for the foreseeable future with a razor thin margin in the Senate folks wanting to create a primary fight (which I agree will weaken Manchin and make him extremely vulnerable, especially if Justice decides to move from the Governor’s Mansion to the Senate) need to pay attention to hard core progressives like me who know WV and the kind of people who live and vote there. And STFU!

    Arizona is one of the few states I’ve never been to so I won’t speak to things there, at least to the level of detail I have about WV. I’ll leave detailed analysis to those who know that part of the country and AZ in particular the way I know a place like WV.

    • I wish Manchin could see that raising the minimum wage will benefit WV. (Less poverty, for one thing. When people have enough money – not huge amounts – they *spend it* and mostly where they live.)

  3. I, too, live in nc. From mayberry, went to Carolina during vietnam & nixon. Hanging onto the majority is the only thing. Didn’t they learn anything from watching moscow mitch the past 10 years?

    • Waving at you from right down the road in Greensboro, apparently they are totally ignorant of the danger they are fomenting. Grrrrrr

  4. I hope they stay out of my district because I think they want to grab my congressional seat in the special election so they can claim another big victory for themselves even though Nina Turncoat has zero interest in the district. But it’s a 50-plus blue district so…. Please if you can, send Shontel Brown a little something some we don’t have to listen to Turncoat run her mouth on the House floor and gloat.

  5. It’s also conceivable that the No Excuses PAC is setting itself up as a big stalking horse for Sinema and Manchin to kick in their nads during the 2022 campaigns. “Look, the radical left is trying to primary us! Told you we were conservatives!” I don’t believe it — most of the folks on the far left have the political acumen of a cinder block — but the possibility exists. It’s also possible an alien will beam into my living room tonight and teach me how to play kazoo. But, well, yeah.

    • Yeah, I share your low opinion of their political acumen, Max. That said, because both Manchin AND Sinema are smarter at politics than they’ll ever be, both sitting Senators could wind up using these fools in just the theoretical way you described. Doubt they like the idea of being used as a stalking horse…kind of like how I don’t like how little of politics they bothered learning these last four years.

    • Max, no alien needed, you just need to listen to the incomparable Bacall teaching Bogie how to play kazoo: You just pucker up and hummmmm.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

The maximum upload file size: 128 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop files here