For The Democrats, Christmas Just Came Early!


Look, I’ve bored you guys silly often enough trying to make the rather arcane budget reconciliation rule more easily understandable. I promise, on my mothers soul that I an not going to do that again today. But budget reconciliation just made it a whole lot more likely that not only will Biden have a successful first term, but may allow the Democrats to steamroll in the 2022 midterms much the way they did in 2018.

Regardless of the depth of your knowledge or understanding of the budget reconciliation rule, you already know this. It is an arcane rule that allows a party to bypass once a year the normal Senate rule requiring a cloture vote of 60 to bring a bill to the floor for a vote. Instead, just so long as the bill involves the budget, and the deficit, it can be brought directly to the floor for a 51 vote majority passage.

That is how the Democrats passed the $1.9trillion Covid relief package that put $1400 in every pocket. They used budget reconciliation, without a single GOP vote in either chamber. And Senate Majority Leader Schumer advised early that he was strongly petitioning the Senate Parliamentarian that the Democrats should get a second bite at the apple, since he claimed that the Democrats used an unused budget reconciliation from the previous year to pass the Covid relief act. That would allow them this years reconciliation to pass their Infrastructure bill.

Earlier this evening, the Senate Parliamentarian issued her ruling on Senator Schumer’s request, and her ruling was a neutron bomb dropped right on the heads of the Senate GOP. Not only did she rule that the Democrats could have that second bite at the apple to pass their infrastructure bill, she went on to rule that the Democrats could have two more bites at the apple on top of that one! This opens up a landscape that the Democrats had never even dreamed of seeing.

The Democrats can now go ahead and pass their infrastructure bill under budget reconciliation, something already wildly popular with the public, including Republicans. But after that, they will get two more chances to pass budget/deficit related bills with a simple 51 vote majority.

My feet aren’t even touching the floor right now. This gives the Democrats a chance to propel forward so much more of their progressive agenda, as long as the majority of the bill impacts either he budget or the deficit. For instance, Biden can now push an aggressive Green New Deal agenda dealing with a massive buy in to promote research and development for new technology in batteries, better solar panels and wind technology. And they can use the second bite of the apple to reform and upgrade the health care industry in the United States, finally making Bernie Sanders a happy camper.

I cannot tell you how important this development is. The GOP looks pathetic enough with incumbents trying to take credit for the sudden influx of cash and benefits stemming from a bill that they all voted against. And they’ll look even worse when they come sniveling around trying to take credit for the benefits to their state for an infrastructure bill that they also uniformly opposed. And don’t think that Democratic ads in the 2022 election season won’t highlight that simple fact.

But what if the Democrats pass massive healthcare reform, lowering the age for Medicare to 55 or 60. Opening Medicare and Medicaid to negotiate drug prices directly with drug companies and opening up the Canadian market? What if they go whole hog and offer a national Medicare buy in, which Biden campaigned on? What does the GOP run on then, when they stand in opposition to everything their own voters want?

This is a political gift that only comes once in a lifetime or two. It gives the Democrats incredible power to pass positive, popular legislation, with widespread public support, including Republican voters. But just as importantly, it forces Mitch McConnell and the rest of the reprobates in the Senate caucus to try to determine just how far they want to go in opposing legislation that is popular with their own voters. Suddenly, it’s a brave new world. Don’t touch that dial.

Follow me on Twitter at @RealMurfster35

Help keep the site running, consider supporting.


  1. Bill Palmer just clued me into this one, Murf. That one move all but guarantees that there shall be nothing but ruins left of the GQP now. Welcome to the wilderness, McConnell. Might want to get started on those retirement plans.

  2. During the turnover between Maddow & O’Donnell she admitted one of her guests had dialed back her euphoria some and he agreed with her guest, having his own career as a senior Senate staffer to draw upon when it comes to the arcane details of how all this works. Still, he agrees that this offers some major possibilities that were unforeseen by most of us. I do however agree with Rachael’s more or less saying that while the formal request for the Parliamentarian’s ruling was recent that Schumer has been holding this card for a while now, just waiting for the right time to lay it on the table. Considering that the Democratic Party is still taking a victory lap (and zinging Republicans over their hypocrisy) over the COVID relief package, what the GOP did in GA and is up to elsewhere AND McConnell’s blunt “stay out of politics” to corporate America I think he picked a pretty good time to play this card. It might also take away one excuse the Manchin types might use to try and scale things back, the excuse being “we only get one more shot at reconcilliation so we need to ‘work with the GOP’ on this and not try to do too much, He and Synema (and maybe a couple of others) as well as “moderate” House Democrats now know that we can actually DO a lot of badly needed stuff and if THEY don’t go along their future in the Party is pretty much over with in most cases. You keep pointing out (correctly) the saying about all politics being local and communities and states (even red ones) will love the positive impact the spending will have back home.

    With the economic growth this will create there will be more money for consumers to spend which means more money for corporate America and big banks/Wall Street. What they lose in tax hikes they will make up in other ways. Sure, they want both/it all but once they crunch the numbers I’m betting they will bitch and moan publicly but behind the scenes withhold support for Republicans who won’t get with the program and even lobby (donate to) some Democrats even.

  3. I’m still not getting your emails. I’ve tried resubscribing, but “address already on file”. What do I do next? Thanks.

    • The newsletter and notifications should start up again. We have a part time webmaster. It’s all I can afford. Please be patient.

  4. It is probably the biggest headline since “Biden and Harris sworn in,” but it’s one of those slow burn headlines because 80% of the country has no idea what this means.

    I’m with your prediction…I think it will mean a healthcare reconciliation and one for green energy. But who knows.

  5. But now we still have to worry about Manchin and the cake lady. I don’t know what Manchin’s problem is unless he really is enamored by the spotlight. He KNOWS that with slimy toad McConnell in charge of the minority, bipartisanship is a pipe dream. I don’t know what the toad has on the others, but he sure keeps them in lockstep when it counts. I believe he is the J. Edgar Hoover of the senate, with dossiers on one and all, though I doubt if Elaine would let him wear an of her frocks. Though maybe she is distracted by all the $$$ she was able to rake in through nepotism on steroids over the past four years


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

The maximum upload file size: 128 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop files here