William Weld nailed it, but will the GOP listen?


For nigh on a year and a half now I have been saying that Donald Trump is literally killing the Republicans as a viable national party going forward. As a result, I have taken my fair share of incoming slings and arrows, telling me what a fool I am, and recounting how many times that the GOP has been left for dead before. But I never predicted the death of the entire GOP, only their demise as a consistent force in national politics.

And so it was with great pleasure that I suddenly found someone, anyone else who agrees with me, and a card carrying Republican to boot. And not just a card carrying Republican, but one with some serious GOP street creds.

That being said, William Weld is rather the pariah in GOP circles right now. A former GOP Massachusetts governor, Weld left the party in 2016 to run as Gary Johnson’s VP candidate on the Libertarian ticket. And now he’s bucking the odds to run against His Lowness in the Republican primaries for President.

I was elated when Weld announced his run, not only because it would force Trump to actually campaign, where he can make a frequent fool of himself, but also because, as Lawrence O’Donnell loves to point out, no incumbent President has ever lost a primary battle, but no incumbent President has been reelected when his primary went beyond South Carolina either. And at least some parts of Trumpmenistan are worried, including the aforementioned South Carolina, which is considering skipping a GOP primary in 2020 if Weld qualifies for the ballot.

After announcing his run, Weld had restricted his appearances largely to network talk shows, including MSNBC. But yesterday he spoke to the annual NAACP convention, something Trump has steadfastly refused to do. And he led his speech off with a bang;

Trump is a raging racist, Okay? He’s a complete and thoroughgoing racist. And he made that choice, a choice a long time ago, when he was engaged in the housing business in New York with his father

This is not going to go over well with The Mango Messiah, I can tell you that. As far as my memory serves, no Republican of any import has come right out and called Glorious Bleater a racist. Even that turncoat Justin Amash split with Trump not over racism, but over the criminality outlined in the Mueller report. But then Weld took it to the next level;

The national Republican Party, has a choice. And a lot of them like to think that it’s a political choice. But it’s not a political choice. It’s a moral choice.

Weld went on to appear on Lawrence O’Donnell’s show last night, when he put the icing on the cake, telling O’Donnell that if the GOP as a party did not repudiate Trump in 2020, it would essentially cease to exist as a party that could win a national election. He stated that sure, the GOP could still capture the “Dixiecrat states,” as he put it, but those would not be enough to win a presidential election in the electoral college.

This could end up working out true either way. Racism works for Trump, but it’s a one trick pony. People who love Trump tolerate racism from him that they would not tolerate from anyone else simply because of his persona. Once Trump is gone, no other candidate can match his persona and audacity, and make racism a staple of his or her platform. But even if Trump loses, the vast majority of “mainstream” conservatives may shy away from rejoining the party, avoiding the stench of racism that Trump has soaked the party in, like so much cheap rum.

Now, let’s be honest, Bill Weld has as much of a chance of beating Donald Trump as a snowflake in Vegas in August. But there are at least three ways that he could seriously damage Trump with his candidacy. Number one, if Weld gets any kind of traction at all, even say 10-15%, he wold become a serious enough candidate to garner more mainstream media time, and drive The $1 Store Caligula insane with his attacks. Trump would not only scream “FAKE NEWS!” about the polls, but if head to head polls showed Trump getting clobbered by Biden, but Weld a closer match with Biden, he could be in real trouble.

Numero dos, we all know that Donald Trump takes rejection about as well as your cat takes a trip to the vet. Namely, howling, spitting, kicking and clawing all the way. If Weld gets any kind of polling success, not only is Trump going to rant and rave about the polls being “fake news,” but he’s also going to start blanket insulting the Weld supporters for their duplicity. Hell, dog’s gotta howl, right? And there are Trump places like New Hampshire, Massachusetts, and California where Weld could come close, if not pull off an upset, causing even more outrage against his voters. The same voters Trump is going to desperately need to come back to him for the general election.

And bringing up the rear, but not by much, is the spoiler effect. Donald Trump is going to need every single vote that he got in 2016, and possibly more to squeak out another electoral college victory in 2020. That is going to include a number of independents and “soft” Republicans that may be sitting on the fence about holding their noses and voting for Trump again. Weld is going to provide the ultimate contrast. A quiet, successful, practical, conservative with a conscience, empathy and moral values. And even after the primaries are over, and Trump is the nominee, Weld may have reminded some of those conservative fence sitters that they can do better, and deserve better, and in so doing, get them to stay home on election day instead of making the same mistake twice.

So, William Weld let the genie out of the bottle, he called Trump a racist, a path I don’t expect any other Republicans to follow. But he also sounded the alarm that The Trumpinator is an existential threat to the GOP as a national party. This is an obvious ploy to gather “traditional” conservatives to his campaign, but that doesn’t make the warning any less dire or true. But if Weld can prove to be a legitimate challenger, he may keep the streak alive of no incumbent being reelected after facing a serious primary challenge. And then the GOP will just have to take its chances and see what arises from the rubble of the Trump experiment.

Help keep the site running, consider supporting.


    • SO do I…Mainly because “never Trumpers” who would otherwise sit out may now go and vote in the primaries just to twist Trump’s tail…

      • I see the potential in this to become a real GOP circus side show — and I can’t wait. Oh, God — here, let me quote Donald Jr. “If it’s what you say it is, I love it!” Yes!

  1. I have a friend who is a lot like Weld. He and I are not on the same page on many policies, and until 2016 he ran one of the biggest Republican clubs in the city and was an officer in the county party. In January 2016 he called me and asked if I could come to his meeting that month so I could see for myself what was happening to a faction of his membership. I went and I observed the Trump contingent in the club insisting that sung the “N” word and saying Obama was “shiftless” was not racist. It was awkward and embarrassing because several African-American judicial candidates and city officials were in attendance. About four months later, my friend quit or was kicked out of the country GOP (“It was one of those ‘I quit,” “You can’t because you’re fired” type of things). He spent the rest of the cycle working on Gary Johnson’s campaign, then after the election started to reorganize the Libertarian Party here, which had come down to one goofy, racist guy. Now he’s endorsed Justin Amash, if Amash runs, but I’m sure if he doesn’t he will be totally behind Weld. My friend still despises Trump.

  2. “I have taken my fair share of incoming slings and arrows.” People should stop throwing the sling itself at you…that’s not how they’re supposed to work.

    On the central theory that Trump will make the GOP non-viable in national elections…I think the data is all over the place on that question. If Trump continues to concentrate down the Republican base, meaning that we continue to see a lot of college educated whites leave the party…in a nation where the white majority is already shrinking this would eventually make the Republicans too weak to win nationally.

    But political parties tend to be good at adapting to survive. It could be that Trump loses, and they lose seats over the course of a few elections, then they stop speaking about Trump, focus on other policies, and over time rebound.

    I think it could go either way. Which is why I think Democrats should evolve and learn to hit them when they’re down. If Trump does push them toward minority party status, we should engage in an all-out war against their shady schemes to protect their power – gerrymandering, court packing, voter suppression.

    And their new chic strategy…get ready because it’s about to become a massive pain in our backsides…nonsense recall efforts. If you lose an election, don’t accept it – force another election right away in order to bog everything down in nonstop campaigning! I’m not joking…GOP-initiated recall efforts are up like 800% in the West.

    • I agree with you on the data, but my reasoning is simple…The GOP is already a “dying” party nationally, made up mostly of older, white, lower educated voters…To survive nationally, they MUST have an infusion of younger, more diverse voters, or the actuarial tables will finish them off…Trump’s flagrant racism and xenophobia have turned those voters away for at least a generation…By the time Trump’s stench of racism dissipates, it will be too late for the prty in its current iteration…

    • And THAT’S the real problem…The issues they’re dealing with are too complex to fit into a handful of words…That’s why I started a Twitter hashtag #FelonInChief…

  3. The only thing that might prevent Weld from doing very well in the primaries would be if some other major Republican who hasn’t drunk from the Trump Kool-Aid bowl sees what’s about to happen and tries to jump to the head of the parade. I’m thinking of John Kassich or Larry Hogan. There’s no way that Trump does well in the Iowa caucus given how the farm economy is reeling from his idiotic tariffs. And it is not possible for Russian hackers to change the results of a caucus. And in the states with primaries, it will be much harder for Russian cyber attacks to control the results than in a general election because it is much harder to predict turnout and figure out how much of the vote has to be altered. This is compounded by the fact that once there is blood in the water, a lot of Democrats might suddenly decide to vote in the Republican primary just to throw Trump an anchor while he’s thrashing about trying to scramble to shore.

    • ” lot of Democrats might suddenly decide to vote in the Republican primary”
      Really? Hmmm…I didn’t know I could vote in a Republican primary?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

The maximum upload file size: 128 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop files here