History may not repeat itself, but it rhymes. Back in the 1950’s, Joseph McCarthy had his own version of today’s Deep State, which he had discovered and was going to root out of government. That conspiracy theory ruined many peoples’ careers and lives, when security clearances were revoked — Robert Oppenheimer is a stellar example — and names began appearing on blacklists. McCarthy was able to harness a couple of simultaneous streams of cultural hysteria, chiefly the fear of America going the way of Russia, into a dictatorship which was called a socialist state, and the fear of the atomic bomb. These formed the fulcrum of Joseph McCarthy’s power.

Throughout all this, the word “socialism” featured prominently. Here’s what Harry Truman had to say about that.

What Joe Biden is doing has been compared to what Franklin D. Roosevelt did to get us out of the Depression. During the Depression, the federal government stepped into many sectors because they had no choice but to do so if the American economy was to be salvaged. The government went into the agricultural sector, the housing sector, the banks, and a lot of private capitalists, who felt thwarted in trying to make a profit, used the pejorative “creeping socialism.” If you want a definition of that term, the best one would probably be “anything that the government is doing.”

Now one of the differences of the 50’s and today, is that both major political parties were viable back then. Today the GOP is coming apart at the seams. So today, “socialism” is the scareword attached to everything the government is doing, but the opposing party has no agenda of its own to replace what the Democrats are doing. All they can do is gin up fear and along comes Kevin McCarthy, right on cue.

We taxed and spent our way out of the Depression, but you’re never going to hear that. You’ll hear conspiracy theories about hamburgers, instead.

The buzzwords are already flying. Lauren Boebert is talking about Marxism being a Ponzi scheme and she is clueless. Marjorie Taylor Greene called MLB pulling its game out of Georgia “corporate communism” and assured one and all that the GOP would unite and fight same. This new iteration of the GOP doesn’t know the difference between any of these theories of government. They’re just words that have a bad sound, chiefly because our history of railing against the post-WWII Russia of Stalin is still fresh in the collective cultural mind, as is Cuba, the Bay of Pigs, Vietnam, the whole enchilada that was the second half of the 20th Century.

The common thread here is provoking unreasoned fear that subversive elements in the government — in this case, President Biden and the entire Democratic party — are undermining America and planning to replace democracy with an “ism” communism, socialism, Marxism, anything with an ism is bad and un American. And all that the GOP knows is that it’s got to convince you that they are going to save you from that, just as Joseph McCarthy sought to convince people back in his day that he was really on to something devastating and pernicious in the government of that day. Now Kevin McCarthy says that he sees with clarity that the government is being controlled by subversives — the “radical left” — and they are going to take away your way of life, starting with your hamburgers. The good that social programs do for Americans is never mentioned.

Effective government is crucial to civilization. Government is that “common power” that Thomas Hobbes referred to.

“During the time men live without a common power to keep them all in awe, they are in that conditions called war; and such a war, as if of every man, against every man.

“To this war of every man against every man, this also in consequent; that nothing can be unjust. The notions of right and wrong, justice and injustice have there no place. Where there is no common power, there is no law, where no law, no injustice. Force, and fraud, are in war the cardinal virtues.

“No arts; no letters; no society; and which is worst of all, continual fear, and danger of violent death: and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short.”

Kevin McCarthy and the Trumpist end of the GOP want you to fear this administration and fear government in general. I guess that’s their official platform, fear. When Trump ran in 2020, they didn’t bother to announce a platform, but seemingly, by default, this is it, now. Fear. Vote Republican and they’ll save you from nameless terrors, or misnamed terrors, in all events.

As Obama said in reference to health care, “They don’t have a plan but they don’t like mine.” Nothing has changed. Paul Ryan used to declaim about “the nightmare that is Obamacare,” and now everything Biden does is characterized as the nightmare of socialism. Like the wolf in a fairy tale, socialism is right outside the door. And the Republicans still don’t have a plan of their own, they just hate his.

That’s it in a nutshell. The GOP is depending upon the crazies to keep them viable and restore them to power. They’re banking on ignorance and conspiracy theory to bring home their bacon and prevail above all. Sweet Jesus.

Help keep the site running, consider supporting.

6 COMMENTS

    • In all things, the ultimate end game is life or death, Hitler guaranteed instant death for anyone going against his game … his fear was total and absolute, his message was broadcast at every source allowed … one newspaper — his, one radio source – his …

      Every other book or pamphlet of outside influence was stacked at street intersections and burned …

      His public rants and rallies, like Trump’s were all about him and the great plan, the super race – his … he cross bred young people to develop his idea of the perfect blond, blue eyed super race … yep, the GOP wants to control everything especially the flow of money to their 1 percenters and to hell with roads and bridges … they dropped a big one in MN on the main highway route up through the twin cities, one I had crossed over many times …

      Some paved roads have disintegrated to the point of forced slow-downs and bump and crack warning signs … once the Interstate reached 25 years old it crossed over the planned life span of the concrete and the old stuff is starting to pop and crack …

      Go figure, what GOOD do these tortured soles, [the GOP], actually do for the public as a unit of Citizens just trying to survive, depending in many instances on Social Security and other government plans?

  1. “Idiot wind. Blowing everytime you move ur teeth. Ur an idiot babe, it’s a wonder u still know how to breathe.” Bob Dylan. Kevin. He’s singing ur song.

  2. Brava! Good discussion. We need to keep informed about what is or is not going on. I appreciate the efforts of dedicated journalists. As we said to one another decades ago, keep on keeping on.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

The maximum upload file size: 128 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop files here